Comments on: Shaftesbury Let’s Talk: a symptom of cultural failure https://jamescousins.com/2017/10/shaftesbury-lets-talk-a-symptom-of-cultural-failure/ A (micro.)blog without a purpose. Fri, 09 Feb 2018 10:10:16 +0000 hourly 1 By: Why potholes are state secrets in Wandsworth - James Cousins https://jamescousins.com/2017/10/shaftesbury-lets-talk-a-symptom-of-cultural-failure/#comment-29074 Fri, 09 Feb 2018 10:10:16 +0000 http://jamescousins.com/?p=10646#comment-29074 […] story started (as quite a few of my recent ones do) at the Shaftesbury Let’s Talk meeting. During the meeting a comment was made by one of the officers […]

]]>
By: “Confidentially agreements, untruths, shifting sands, tall walls, guard dogs were all put in place to ensure the Council, not its residents, would be calling the shots”, speech by Cllr Candida Jones to Council – Wandsworth Labour https://jamescousins.com/2017/10/shaftesbury-lets-talk-a-symptom-of-cultural-failure/#comment-29072 Wed, 13 Dec 2017 12:27:52 +0000 http://jamescousins.com/?p=10646#comment-29072 […] Cllr Cousins’ blog is here: http://jamescousins.com/2017/10/shaftesbury-lets-talk-a-symptom-of-cultural-failure/ […]

]]>
By: Shaftesbury’s Let’s Talk - what was said - James Cousins https://jamescousins.com/2017/10/shaftesbury-lets-talk-a-symptom-of-cultural-failure/#comment-29071 Sun, 10 Dec 2017 09:55:36 +0000 http://jamescousins.com/?p=10646#comment-29071 […] last blog post was about the Shaftesbury Let’s Talk meeting, a rather dispiriting experience to say the least. National and local politics have been similarly […]

]]>
By: Robin https://jamescousins.com/2017/10/shaftesbury-lets-talk-a-symptom-of-cultural-failure/#comment-29070 Mon, 23 Oct 2017 17:33:46 +0000 http://jamescousins.com/?p=10646#comment-29070 When you say “they all expressed their discomfort and unhappiness” – how do you know this? Most people were silent and said no words at all in the meeting, and I can’t remember any polling occurring on the way out, asking us what we each thought. It was clear from what people themselves admitted or were overheard discussing on leaving, that some came to the meeting from Tooting or other areas outside Shaftesbury. This meant that a meeting designed for locals was diverted by too many who were not local. It doesn’t mean the issues of Tooting Common aren’t important or that people around Lavender Hill don’t care about anything beyond the immediate area, simply that it left you wondering if people have to go to Tooting or Northcote Road to raise issues directly about (for example) Shaftesbury schools or rubbish collection on Eversleigh Road.

As a Governor of Shaftesbury Park school, you must have seen the irony in the screaming and abuse hurled around – if a teacher at the school experienced the same from a child there, would that be seen as acceptable by parents of other children whose class may be being disrupted? I’m sure it would not have been acceptable. Nor should it have been, really, from grown adults, no matter how passionately they felt about the issues. Personally I felt sorry for those who had hoped to hear more from the council officers present and for the person chairing the meeting, and all 3 of you Councillors, for whom the evening was pretty much a waste of time – it was disappointing you all didn’t show more support for the lady who was chairing the meeting….she wasn’t local, clearly, and you were one of her hosts – it doesn’t matter if you aren’t all from the same political party, you all had an equal duty to work together to make that meeting more productive. You yourself could have spoken out to make it a better meeting, and brought order to it, if you had wished to, but you didn’t. You could have done so if only for the sake of the officers who gave up their evening and sat patiently and quietly on the sidelines, there to serve the residents and councillors present without recourse to political point scoring.

]]>
By: James Cousins https://jamescousins.com/2017/10/shaftesbury-lets-talk-a-symptom-of-cultural-failure/#comment-29069 Tue, 17 Oct 2017 17:36:40 +0000 http://jamescousins.com/?p=10646#comment-29069 In reply to altoclef44.

The change was mainly done as part of a rebrand to start promoting the council leader more prominently (his picture is about a quarter of the leaflet now); the name change just a happy coincidence…

]]>
By: altoclef44 https://jamescousins.com/2017/10/shaftesbury-lets-talk-a-symptom-of-cultural-failure/#comment-29068 Tue, 17 Oct 2017 15:28:55 +0000 http://jamescousins.com/?p=10646#comment-29068 I have attended many of these meetings – in the past called “Listening to You”, after which the title was changed – possibly we we accused them again and again of not listening. The behaviour Cllrs. Cook and Senior is appalling. Shouting?

]]>
By: James Cousins https://jamescousins.com/2017/10/shaftesbury-lets-talk-a-symptom-of-cultural-failure/#comment-29067 Mon, 16 Oct 2017 21:11:58 +0000 http://jamescousins.com/?p=10646#comment-29067 In reply to Cyril Richert.

I was thinking more about when councillors have to act as decision makers (from planning, to trees, to everything else). If there’s that degree of separation it might make them less susceptible to bias. I accept it’s a weak argument.

]]>
By: Cyril Richert https://jamescousins.com/2017/10/shaftesbury-lets-talk-a-symptom-of-cultural-failure/#comment-29066 Mon, 16 Oct 2017 13:45:00 +0000 http://jamescousins.com/?p=10646#comment-29066 A bit difficult to represent residents as a ward councillor and “be separate from residents” at the same time… That’s challenging the principle of representative democracy.

]]>